Metal roofs can leak when screws begin backing out.- The Easiest Way To Get Your Roof Replaced - A Roofing Company That's Local, Honest & Family Owned

Why Asphalt Roofing Outperforms Metal Roofing


When homeowners face the decision of choosing roofing materials, the debate between asphalt and metal roofing often takes center stage. Both options present unique benefits, but this guide will delve into the specific advantages of asphalt roofing over metal roofing. From aesthetics to functionality, discover why asphalt may be the superior choice for your home. Explore our roofing materials.

1. Waterproofing Challenges with Surface-Screwed Metal Roofing

A significant concern with ag-panel metal roofing comes from the screws used to secure the panels. Over time, these screws may partially pull out, raising the neoprene grommet meant to keep water from entering the hole created by the screw. This compromise can lead to leaks and water damage within the structure, a problem less likely to occur with asphalt roofing.

2. Cost-Effectiveness vs. Metal Roofing

Asphalt shingles are widely recognized for their affordability, especially when compared to metal roofing. While the initial cost of metal may seem competitive, the long-term expense can add up, making asphalt a budget-friendly option.

3. Aesthetic Appeal Compared to Metal Roofing

Unlike metal roofing, asphalt shingles are available in a plethora of colors, styles, and textures. Metal roofing may not offer the same range of aesthetic options, limiting customization possibilities.

4. Noise Level in Metal Roofing

One of the common complaints about metal roofing is the noise level during heavy rain or hail storms. Asphalt roofing provides a quieter alternative, enhancing indoor comfort.

5.Ease of Installation Over Metal Roofing

Installing asphalt roofing is typically a quicker and simpler process than metal roofing. This ease of installation not only shortens the project timeline but often reduces the overall cost.

6. Energy Efficiency: Asphalt vs. Metal Roofing

While metal roofing can reflect heat, it may not insulate as effectively as asphalt shingles. This energy efficiency translates into potential savings on heating and cooling bills.

7. Compatibility with Various Roof Shapes

Asphalt shingles are versatile and can be adapted to various roof shapes and sizes. Metal roofing may not be suitable for more complex or intricate roof designs.


The decision between asphalt shingles and metal roofing is multifaceted. The specific challenges and considerations highlighted above make asphalt roofing a more appealing option for many homeowners in North Carolina. Trust MCSquared Roofing to guide you through these choices, offering instant online ballpark estimates and tailored solutions. Need more reasons to choose an asphalt shingle roof over metal roofing?  See how asphalt can protect against hail better than steel.

Instantly Compare the Cost of Metal Vs Asphalt on Your Home